Excerpts from nist.gov:
Firefighters regularly risk their lives in dangerous situations, but most deaths on duty are not directly caused by fire or smoke inhalation. Instead, approximately 40% of on-duty fatalities come from sudden cardiac death.
Now, researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and their colleagues have used a form of AI known as machine learning to accurately identify abnormal cardiac rhythms in firefighters. The researchers hope their work will eventually lead to a portable heart monitor that firefighters could wear to catch early warning signs of heart trouble and prompt them to seek medical attention before it’s too late.
The team, which includes researchers from NIST, the University of Rochester and Google, published its results in the Fire Safety Journal.
Sudden cardiac death claimed the lives of 36 firefighters on duty in 2022, according to the National Fire Protection Association. Sudden cardiac death occurs when an irregular heart rhythm causes the heart to stop pumping blood, most commonly due to a heart attack. Sudden cardiac events kill on-duty firefighters at twice the rate of police officers and four times the rate of other emergency responders.
Firefighters work in remarkably strenuous environments, carrying heavy objects, climbing stairs, and enduring extreme temperatures with a limited ability to cool off. And while they may experience significant discomfort, reports have shown that firefighters often try to push through these situations without realizing they may be at risk for sudden cardiac death.
To address this issue, the NIST researchers got in touch with colleagues from the University of Rochester School of Nursing. A decade ago, Rochester researcher Mary Carey and her colleagues collected 24 hours of electrocardiogram (ECG) data from each of 112 firefighters, who had electrodes strapped to their chests. The ECG data encompassed 16-hour on-duty shifts and eight-hour off-duty shifts during which the firefighters engaged in their daily activities such as answering fire and medical calls, exercising, eating, resting and sleeping.
The researchers then used machine learning and the Rochester dataset to build what they call the Heart Health Monitoring (H2M) model. They trained H2M with 12-second segments of a large portion of the ECG data. Individual heartbeats in the ECGs were classified as normal beats or abnormal beats indicative of irregular heart rhythms such as an atrial fibrillation or ventricular tachycardia.
Once H2M was trained and validated, it analyzed firefighter ECG data from the Rochester dataset that it had not previously seen. When presented with approximately 6,000 abnormal ECG samples, H2M identified them correctly with about 97% accuracy. As a check, H2M was also trained using ECG datasets from non-firefighters. When it used this non-firefighter data, H2M had an error rate of about 40% in identifying cardiac events in the firefighter data.
In the future, the researchers envision that this model could be incorporated into portable heart monitors that firefighters could wear on duty to warn them of cardiac irregularities in real time. Such an AI assistant could be the next best thing to a cardiologist accompanying a crew fighting a fire.
“This technology can save lives,” said Tam, adding that this approach could be broadened to help other groups if the AI is trained with appropriate ECG datasets. “It could benefit not only firefighters but other first responders and additional populations in the general public.”
#1 by crabbymilton on July 13, 2023 - 12:58 PM
It all boils down to individual cases. It’s up to people not to become out of shape to the point that it puts you at great risk. That doesn’t mean that a young healthy person can’t just suddenly pass away. Then there are fat middle aged and old people that live to age 100. Common sense and knowing the risks are the key.
#2 by Tom on July 13, 2023 - 12:48 PM
Maybe these larger agencies should look into requiring physical fitness exams/working out. For the argument that “people will never buy into it”, the fire service implemented and required SCBA’s in the 70’s/80’s. I’m sure that was met with much more resistance but it eventually stuck and there is overall VERY strong compliance with SCBA usage today. Maybe these agencies should develop a system for getting echocardiograms for firefighters. Stress tests only can detect if you are having a heart attack during the test, yet most departments issue the test on a yearly basis. An echocardiogram can detect coronary occlusion- one of the leading causes of heart attack and LODD in the fire service. Maybe these large agencies should look into how to solve the problem rather than come up with a new gadget that will never be implemented.
#3 by Mike on July 13, 2023 - 11:30 AM
Bill, I am not against this at all. I just think that before we go doing more things we need to address the other issues. I’m glad that things like this are getting talked about and research is there.
#4 by BMurphy on July 13, 2023 - 9:56 AM
Mike, your points are very valid and well-thought, but are you inferring that because of some hurdles and difficulties this is not a worthwhile pursuit?
While these obstacles to firefighter health will always present varying degrees of challenge to the fire service, progressive solutions such as this should be adopted as they provide a means to save lives now, regardless of any individual or organizational challenges or issues that would otherwise take time, dedication and greater resources to overcome.
The argument for funding and implementation appears strong enough to be heard and embraced by most all.
#5 by Mike on July 12, 2023 - 1:53 PM
This is great but there are many factors that lead to heart attacks: not enough manpower to complete tasks on the fireground, lack of actual fireground training, lack of physical fitness, lack of physicals and doing things like heart scans, lack of proper rehab on alarms, lack of scba use in areas that need scba use or during overhaul, lack of proper nutrition and proper sleep. You are expected to go from 0-100 with in seconds and the adrenaline dump can even cause heart issues.
Bottom line is all of this costs money and most employers don’t want to pay for anything.