From Phil Stenholm:
Another installment about History of Evanston Fire Department
THIS MEANS WAR!
During the decade of the 1920’s, as the Evanston Fire Department was expanding to an 84-man force, sixty new firemen were hired. During the decade of the 1930’s, however, only nine new men were hired, and only four during the height of the Depression 1932 – 1939.
The four men who were hired between 1932 and 1939 were hired off the same civil service list. They were one of dozens of unemployed men who took a long-awaited civil service test for the position of fireman that was given by the Evanston Civil Service Board in September 1935. Only 18 passed the test, and only four of the them were hired during the life of the list, all four in 1936. Each of them would go on to have stellar careers with the EFD: James Mersch Sr would retire as an assistant chief (and platoon commander) in 1958, George Jasper retired as a captain (Engine Co. 23) in 1963, Ervin Lindeman retired as a captain (Truck Co. 22) in 1967, and Lester Breitzman retired in 1971 after 35 years of service, the last seven as chief.
The United States of America entered World War II following the December 7, 1941 attack on Pearl Harbor by naval and air forces of the Empire of Japan. George Jasper was the first Evanston firefighter to be drafted into the U. S. military in June 1942. The Evanston Auxiliary Fire Service (EAFS) was organized that same month, mainly in preparation for a possible enemy attack by air raid or sabotage on Chicago, but also to help offset an anticipated manpower shortage in the Evanston Fire Department during the war.
The EAFS operated with the EFD’s reserve city service ladder truck (Truck No. 3), a 300-GPM booster-pumper (Engine No. 7) that had been transferred to the street department for use as a utility truck in 1938 before being returned to the Evanston Fire Department in March 1942 and restored by EFD mechanics as a fully-functioning firefighting apparatus, and three government surplus U. S. Civilian Defense 250-GPM pumps mounted on trailers received by the EAFS in November 1942 that could be pulled when needed by street department trucks.
Lloyd Winne was appointed Chief of the EAFS, with Jared Johnson and M. E. Carter serving as the two company commanders. The EAFS was divided in two, with half of the men organized as Truck Co. 3 at Station # 3, and the other half organized as Engine Co. 7 at Station # 4. To make room for the EAFS engine company at Station # 4, the EFD’s lone-remaining spare rig — Engine No. 6, the 1917 Seagrave 300-GPM booster pumper that had been rebuilt as a 500-GPM “Suburbanite” TCP at the Seagrave factory in 1930 — was relocated to Fire Station # 2.
The EAFS was disbanded in 1944 after its 300-GPM booster pumper (Engine No. 7) broke down and could not be repaired. The apparatus was subsequently dismantled for spare parts that were used to keep the other 1917 rigs running, most especially the venerable 1917 Seagrave 750-GPM TCP that had been in continuous front-line service for more than 25 years, first as Engine No. 1 from 1918-37, and then as Engine No. 4 since January 1938, but was showing signs of extensive rust damage on the chassis, axles, drive-train, and engine block.
The Evanston Fire Department had difficulty maintaining minimum staffing for shifts during World War II, especially in 1944 and 1945. By November 1943, all civil service lists had been exhausted, and there were no qualified men available to be hired as firefighters. Many of the men who had been on civil service lists in 1942 and 1943 were drafted before they could be hired, and others who were hired were drafted almost immediately afterward.
The firefighters who did not enter the military — many of whom were veteran firemen nearing retirement — were often compelled to work their day off and receive just a straight-time comp day they could bank and use later. During the war it was not unusual for an Evanston firefighter to work 72 consecutive hours and then receive just a straight-time comp day, except he couldn’t actually use it because of manpower shortages.
This caused a morale problem throughout the EFD, and many older firefighters chose to retire rather than accept the burden of forced overtime. In fact, as many Evanston firemen retired during the years 1943-45 as during the previous ten years combined! And as more men retired, an even greater burden fell upon the men who remained.
A year prior to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, the most costly fire in Evanston’s history (to date) occurred when Northwestern University’s Technological Institute — which was under construction — was destroyed ($620,000 loss) on the morning of December 2, 1940. 64 Evanston firefighters, assisted by Chicago F. D. Engine Co. 70, Engine Co. 110, and Engine Co. 112, battled the blaze well into the afternoon as a cold north wind fanned the flames, threatening other N. U. properties to the south. Evanston and Chicago firefighters poured more than a million gallons of water onto the conflagration before eventually bringing the blaze under control, thanks in no small part to an abrupt change in wind-direction from northwest to south. Eight months later (August 1941), another fire caused heavy-damage ($35,000 loss) to the Pontiac Sales automobile dealership at 1819 Ridge Ave.
On February 23, 1941, the EFD responded into Wilmette and assisted the Wilmette F. D. battling a large and dangerous fire at the Vitreous Enamel Company factory at 1419 Central Ave. Just five days earlier, veteran EFD Lt. Dan McKimmons (Truck Co. 2) had narrowly escaped death after becoming trapped in a smoke-charged basement while battling a blaze in an apartment building at 1015 Dempster Street. Suffocating from smoke inhalation, Lt. McKimmons was rescued just in the nick of time and resuscitated by Assistant Chief Tom McEnery, Lt. William Elliott, and firemen Ed Hanrahan, John Reddick, Lou Morgan, George Thompson, Herb Claussen, and Fred Godeman.
Several other veteran Evanston firemen were not quite so fortunate, however. Fireman Fred Korn retired with a disability pension in 1939 after suffering a career-ending arm injury, Albert Balmes (Engine Co. 5) died as the result of a head injury suffered during a fight at his niece’s weddng reception in July 1940, Walt Caple retired on a disability pension in 1941, Lt. Carl Dorband (Engine Co. 3) died of a heart attack while sitting in front of Fire Station # 3 on a lazy Sunday afternoon in May 1942, and Capt. Anthony Steigelman (Engine Co. 1) and Lt. William Elliott (Truck Co. 1) each died while off duty, Steigelman in June 1944, and Elliott in January 1945.
The first (and only) fatality to result from a traffic collision involving an Evanston Fire Department vehicle occurred during World War II, on the afternoon of Sunday, October 10, 1943. Truck Co. 2 was headed eastbound on Central Street, en route to Dyche Stadium for a drill with the EAFS, and as rookie Fireman Hjalmar Okerwall turned the lumbering 1937 Seagrave 65-foot aerial ladder truck northbound onto Ashland Avenue, an automobile occupied by an elderly couple heading westbound on Central Street failed to stop and collided with the fire truck. The car’s female passenger was killed.
Pingback: Evanston Fire Department history Part 43 « chicagoareafire.com
#1 by Phil Stenholm on November 5, 2021 - 5:22 PM
MIKE L: I think back then, for it to have been considered a LODD in the traditional sense of what that meant at the time, the firefighter would have had to die as the result of an external cause, like from smoke inhalation and/or burns at a fire, or blunt-force trauma from a building collapse, or in a traffic collision while responding to or returning from an alarm, or in a training exercise, or as the result of an accident at the firehouse.
Besides the three LODD everybody in the EFD knows about (firemen George Stiles and William Craig of Engine Co. 1 getting crushed after a wall collapsed onto them at the Mark Manufacturing Company fire in December 1905, and FF/PM Marty Leoni of Truck Co. 21 dying from smoke inhalation after becoming trapped in a 2nd floor flat while battling a house fire at 1927 Jackson Avenue in July 1985), three other Evanston firefighters died while on duty, and all three died of a heart attack, and none of them are (or ever have been) considered a LODD.
Besides Lt. Carl Dorband’s fatal heart attack suffered while sitting outside Fire Station # 3 in May 1942, Capt. Ed Hanrahan (Engine Co. 1) suffered a fatal heart attack while playing handball in the basement handball court of Fire Station #1 in 1949, and Assistant Chief J. E. Mersch (chief of the Fire Prevention Bureau) suffered a fatal heart attack behind the wheel of his staff car while leading the Fire Prevention Week parade up Orrington Avenue in October 1950.
Lt. Dorband was 50 years old and was eligible to retire when he died, and Assistant Chief Mersch was 67 and planning to retire after 45 years of service with the EFD, but Capt. Hanrahan was only 44. He was one of the twenty men hired on November 1, 1927, had been a long-time buggy-driver for Chief Hofstetter. He was promoted to lieutenant in 1944, and just two years after that he was promoted to captain and appeared to be on the fast-track to becoming a chief officer. But he was also suffering from what is known today as morbid obesity, and part of his weight-reduction diet & exercise plan was to play handball.
Depending on how you look at it, there were three other EFD deaths that were maybe LODD by today’s standards.
Lt. John Watson (assistant company officer of Engine Co. 2 ) died of an accidental aspirin overdose in January 1914, 55-year old Assistant Chief Ed Johnson (company officer of Truck Co. 1 and a platoon commander, and coincidentally Chief Hofstetter’s brother-in-law) suffered a fatal heart attack while being driven home from work by Fireman Dominic Bartholme in October 1932, and 34-year old Fireman Frederick Walters (a pipeman assigned to Engine Co. 5) died from a pulmonary embolism at Evanston Hospital two days after being struck in the chest by a loose roll of wet hose while standing on the back step of Engine No. 5 while the company was returning to quarters from a Wilmette F. D. – Evanston F. D. joint training exercise at Gillson Park in October 1936.
Lt. Watson suffered from endless severe pain and headaches after sustaining a back injury from falling backwards from the attic to the 2nd floor while battling a house fire at 552 Forest Avenue in February 1911. And since the EFD’s pension system was not yet up & running in 1914 (and wouldn’t be until January 1916), Watson felt he had to continue working to support his family, and so he chose to self-medicate with aspirin powder.
Fireman Walters’ death was not ruled a LODD by the pension board because he was fine for two days after the incident, and his doctor couldn’t absolutely confirm the embolism was caused by the aforementioned blunt force trauma from the flying hose roll or by a coincidental unrelated blood clot of unknown cause.
Since Walters had already accrued ten years on the job, the way pensions were administered prior to 1947 meant his survivors pension would have been the same whether his death occurred as the result of an on duty incident or for some other unrelated reason, so the circumstances of his death were not investigated any further.
And then of course there are the many, many deaths that have occurred over the years (especially before the advent of SCBA) from heart attack, COPD, lung cancer, and other chronic illnesses that could probably be linked directly or indirectly to being a firefighter, but cannot be connected to any incident or event in particular.
#2 by Mike L on November 4, 2021 - 4:39 PM
Interesting that Lt Dorband was not considered an LODD. Different era, I suppose.
#3 by Phil Stenholm on November 4, 2021 - 3:00 PM
EVANSTON FIRE DEPARTMENT APPARATUS – NOVEMBER 1940
FRONT-LINE
TRUCK No. 1 – 1924 Seagrave 85-ft TDA (equipped with ladder pipe)
TRUCK No. 2 – 1937 Seagrave “Service” 65-ft aerial ladder truck with 50-gal booster (had enclosed three-man cab)
ENGINE No. 1:- 1937 Seagrave Model “80-E” 750-GPM TCP with 80 gal booster
ENGINE No. 2 – 1927 Seagrave “Standard” 1000-GPM TCP with 50 gal booster
ENGINE No. 3 – 1937 Seagrave Model “80-E” 750-GPM TCP with 80 gal booster
ENGINE No. 4 – 1917 Seagrave 750 TCP with 50 gal chemical tank & red line
ENGINE No. 5 – 1927 Seagrave “Standard” 1000-GPM TCP with 50 gal booster
NOTE: The two 1937 pumpers had semi-enclosed “safety cabs” with open-air canopy-protected four-man rear-facing bench seat, and the two 1000-GPM “Standard” pumpers carried three-inch hose in addition to standard pumper hose load.
RESERVE APPARATUS
ENGINE No. 6 – 1917 Seagrave “Suburbanite” 500 GPM TCP with 50-gal booster
NOTE: Built originally as a 300 GPM chemical & hose booster-pumper in 1917; this rig was rebuilt as a “Suburbanite” pumper at the Seagrave factory in 1930
TRUCK No. 3 – 1917 Seagrave Model “E” city service truck equipped with 50 gal chemical tank & red line, and ladder inventory included a ground-based 55-ft Bangor ladder that required four men to raise with tormentor poles
NOTE: All of the rigs were equipped with Mars FL-8 lights, Seagrave Delco-Remy “Twin Blast” sirens, and bells, with a “steady” red light attached to the driver’s side and a “steady” green light attached to the passenger’s side
OTHER:
CHIEF’S AUTOMOBILE: 1937 Ford Tudor Deluxe sedan
FIRE PREVENTION INSPECTOR’S AUTOMOBILE: 1936 Ford Tudor Deluxe sedan
NOTE: Both automobiles were equipped with factory-installed sirens, red (driver’s side) and green (passenger side) lenses over the spotlights, and the Ford “police package” included a Motorola “Police Cruiser” AM radio receiver tuned to Chicago Police frequency
#4 by Phil Stenholm on November 4, 2021 - 2:15 PM
EVANSTON FIRE DEPARTMENT ROSTER – NOVEMBER 1940
78 members
CHIEF FIRE MARSHAL:
Chief Albert Hofstetter
FIRE PREVENTION BUREAU:
2nd Assistant Chief J. E. Mersch
COMPANY OFFICER & PLATOON COMMANDER::
1st Assistant Chief Tom McEnery (Truck Co. 1)
3rd Assistant Chief Carl Windelborn (Truck Co. 2)
COMPANY OFFICER
Capt. Anthony Steigelman (Engine Co. 1)
Capt. Henry Dorband (Engine Co. 2)
Capt. Ed McEnery (Engine Co. 3)
Capt. Michael Garrity (Engine Co. 4)
Capt. Henry Tesnow (Engine Co. 5)
ASSISTANT COMPANY OFFICER:
Lt. William Elliott (Truck Co. 1)
Lt. Dan McKimmons (Truck Co. 2)
Lt. Frank Sherry Sr (Engine Co. 1)
Lt. Harry Jasper (Engine Co. 2)
Lt. Carl Dorband (Engine Co. 3)
Lt. Ed Newton (Engine Co. 4)
Lt. Jim Geishecker (Engine Co. 5)
MECHANIC:
J. K. “Karl” Wilen
Norm Fochs
CHIEF’S DRIVER
John Schmidt
Ed Hanrahan
FIREMAN I:
Lawrence Ahrens
Frank Altenberg
Harold Anderson
John Anderson
John Balmes
Charles Bammesberger
Dominic Batholome
Lester Breitzman
William Brundage
Walter Caple
Herb Claussen
Lincoln Dickinson
Roger Elliott
Edward C. Fahrbach
Edward G. Fahrbach
Ronald Ford
John Gleeson
Fred Godeman
Herman Godeman
Knud Hanson
Walter Janz
George Jasper
John Kabel
Lou Knockaert
Max Kraatz
Charles Lapp
John Lee
Bernie Lindberg
John Lindberg
Ervin Lindeman
John Linster
James Mersch Sr
John M. Mersch
John Monks
Lou Morgan
Jerry Moriarty
William Murphy
Harry Nelson
Charles Novak
Michael Olk
William Owens
George Paugels
Herman Peters
John Reddick
William Richards
William Rohrer
John Schippman
William Schreiber
Fred Schumacher
George Thompson
Ted Thompson
Francis Williams
George Wilson
Arthur Windelborn
Herman Windelborn
FIREMAN II
Peter Sasgen (replaced Fred Korn in 1939)
FIREMAN III
George Wicker (replaced Phil Line in 1940)
John Biddle (replaced Albert Balmes in 1940)