It appears that the time has come to set some ground rules and discuss some policies for this blog.
We have a fairly strong readership, and many satisfied readers. We have a large group of responsible and dedicated contributors who are the backbone for the content found on this site.
So, let’s talk about making comments. An open forum is healthy. It can be both fun and informative. It can also be hurtful and vengeful. As the webmaster, some time ago I made the conscious decision to unlock the review period for those posting comments. It became too cumbersome to preview all posts prior to approving them, and it often introduced lengthy delays from when the comment was made and when it was posted.
Most comments are fine, but recently we’ve had some critiquing that went further than this blog may have ever intended to have happen. It’s an evolving process that requires periodic review.
Several readers have in the past tried to offer their interpretation of what this blog should be, by asking others to keep their critiques and criticisms to a minimum on this forum. As the webmaster, I try to remain neutral and let the forum run on it’s own.
I think that I speak (I’m presuming that I do) for the majority of readers when I say that we’d rather have the continued support and submissions from our regular contributors, than the occasional armchair quarterbacking from a small group of anonymous readers. In the years that this site has been up, I can probably count on one hand the number of comments that I’ve stopped from being posted due to what I felt was inappropriate. These comments came from totally anonymous sources. It’s not about censorship or free speech, both of which I am always conscious of, and I support. It’s about common courtesy and common sense.
We can’t blame the messenger for conveying something that may not be perfect, safe, according to NFPA, department protocol, or common sense. That responsibility belongs with the message itself. That being said, this is not our goal. We all understand that we live in a time where instant notification of events with images provides access to many where previously something may have only been seen by a few.
So, if you’ve got something to say, stop and think about it before you hit send. If you really feel strongly about an issue, then back it up by providing your name like so many of our readers do.
As the webmaster, I will take it upon myself in the future to withdraw something that may incite negativity that is not appropriate for this forum. It’s clearly a judgement call on my part, but that will be the direction for now. Again, the blog is a fluid environment that is constantly changing.
Should you wish to engage in critiquing the minutia found in an image, there is another very popular site which is largely dedicated to doing just that.
I welcome your comments and thoughts, and I thank you for visiting this site. Additionally, I wish to extend my apologies to those who bore the brunt of this insensitivity, as this was never the intent of this site.
#1 by Fartin' Fred on April 4, 2014 - 6:52 PM
No problem, I got your cab, Milton. Hopefully after 9 beers & a free cab ride home, ya won’t be crabby–CHEERS! ????????????????????????????
????????????????????????????????????
#2 by Crabby Milton on April 4, 2014 - 9:22 AM
That’s the spirit Fred. I have to drive so limit mine to 2 unless you want to pay for a cab. 🙂 But that’s what’s nice about this site, we may disagree from time to time but all in all, just a bunch of well meaning people of good will on here and strife won’t last long under such circumstances.
#3 by Fartin' Fred on April 4, 2014 - 9:10 AM
Let’s all go out for BEERS: 8-9 a piece, minimum! BOTTOMS-UP!
#4 by fmddc1 on April 4, 2014 - 5:58 AM
You guy’s are right! We (including myself) get carried away from time to time. those of us who where or are currently in the fire service love to break “b’s” as we did or do around the house. But you guy’s are right, this is not the forum to do so. I gave almost 20 years of my life both in the suburbs and the city and left due to political pressure. I no longer live in IL so it’s nice to visit here and see all the goings on around the departments. I will (in the future) keep my (negative comments) silent. Thank’s for all you guys do to keep this sight awesome!
#5 by Crabby Milton on April 4, 2014 - 5:58 AM
If I was ever rude on here, please accept my apology. I think all of us in life don’t mean to get carried away when trying to inject mild humor or even a bit of sarcastic dialog when we don’t agree with an issue but human nature takes over at least for me. I applaud the “owner” of this site/blog for issuing that gentle reminder before things get truly ugly. I have seen many such sites where the webmaster constantly lectures everybody but when push comes to shove, he or she looks the other way and the you know what flys all the time and soon the origianl post gets sidetracked. I love this site. The information and updates are great plus so many pictures to chose from for my screen saver.
#6 by spoung45 on April 4, 2014 - 12:18 AM
Most of the time I am serious with my comments. I know my last comment on the new buggies was not, it was just me being sarcastic. If it was taken the wrong way I am sorry. I can be sarcastic at times, but I will not do that here anymore if it can be taken the wrong way.
#7 by MJ on April 3, 2014 - 10:14 PM
Webmaster-
I agree with your statements. I have wondered myself about some comments that have been made from bloggers. In my opinion, they were down right rude. I appreciate the genuine CFD fire buffs who contribute their information. It too, for me, has become a daily habit to look at the posts from all the resource networks. Thank you for the site and the continued ability to network.
#8 by T. B. on April 3, 2014 - 10:01 PM
Steve, Tom and Admin,
Thank you for shedding light on how my comments as well as others, may be or might have been taken in the wrong way. I do get it! For some, the older we get the more critical we can be. We can also make comments or observations which can be perceived as being personal, when that is not at all the intention. I too feel that this site is the pulse of the fire service in our area. To be honest, I’d love for every firefighter to be able to live long enough to love their children and grandchildren for a long time. That is my excuse for such a huge emphasis on PPE. I know they have always taught in the ISO Class that you can’t be the PPE police, but it is such an easy thing to do to protect yourself. I do promise, no more nonsense!
Kudos and thanks for this great site!
#9 by Tom Foley on April 3, 2014 - 6:37 PM
As someone who has moderated a chat forum in a completely different industry in the past, I’ve been in your position.
That said, I have no where near the the experience or first hand working knowledge of fire operations as some I’ve seen on the site. And, that’s what makes this blog so interesting to me!
I hope there is also a place for people like me who are very interested in following the goings on at fire departments in the Chicago area.
I also hope some questions about operations are allowed for people like me to continue to learn and follow this element of public safety. I’d like to think I’ve also asked questions in a respectful, non-threatening manner… for which I’ve always received an equally respectful response from the site’s members.
Thank you for this wonderful site and to all the contributors! I have it booked marked and visit it daily to keep up. Makes for a fun hobby and helps me become better educated. (I’ve personally found myself explaining different levels of alarms, mutual aide, and why engines are often sent with ambos for medical assistance calls to all sorts of everyday people.)
Thanks again for the resource!
#10 by Admin on April 3, 2014 - 7:09 PM
Tom, thank you. Your questions are always welcome, and I know that several of our readers enjoy the opportunity of providing answers.