Excerpts from the Woodstockindependentcom:
Service cuts at Woodstock’s hospital could cost the Woodstock Fire/Rescue District hundreds of thousands of dollars in additional equipment and personnel.
About 44 percent of Woodstock-area ambulance transports in September bypassed Centegra Hospital-Woodstock for other hospitals, according to data from WFRD. By contrast, in January, about 10 percent of WFRD’s transports went elsewhere.
In mid-August, Centegra-Woodstock stopped accepting most inpatient admissions. The hospital continues to run a basic emergency room, and it offers other services, but patients who need overnight stays are being treated at Centegra-Huntley or Centegra-McHenry. That means WFRD’s ambulance runs for people with conditions ranging from serious allergic reactions to pneumonia must be transported out of town.
The additional drive time which comes with taking many patients from Woodstock to Huntley or McHenry has Fire Chief Michael Hill thinking about the future. For decades, Woodstock’s ambulance service has been structured for paramedics to deliver patients to the emergency room and be back on the road quickly — sometimes in just five or 10 minutes.
Now, Hill said, a trip to an out-of-town hospital can take an ambulance out of service for 35 to 40 minutes. For a district that runs about 12 calls a day, that time adds up. On occasion, if all three WFRD ambulances are out, crews from neighboring towns are called in to cover.
“If you go to the Woodstock hospital and drop off your patients, you’re ready to respond. An ambulance is available,” Hill said. “If you’re out in McHenry or Huntley, you’re too far away. You’re not available.”
A Centegra official said the health system is working with WFRD and that Woodstock’s ER can provide emergency care to the vast majority of patients.
“Our collaboration with Woodstock EMS is a work in progress, and we continue to discuss the ways to best serve patients in Woodstock and its surrounding communities,” Catie Schmit, Centegra’s director of emergency services, wrote in an email. “We are identifying additional opportunities for education to be sure patients are taken to the emergency room that provides the most appropriate care for their conditions.”
Hill cautioned WFRD’s most recent data only takes into account about a month’s worth of transports, so it’s still too early to decide if the district will need to hire more staff or buy another ambulance. But he said there’s a chance WFRD — and, by extension, taxpayers — will need to spend more to make up for the reduction in services at Woodstock’s hospital.
Buying a new ambulance would cost about $210,000, and hiring more employees to staff it would cost easily more than $100,000 a year in salaries, benefits and other expenses.
In the case of walk-ins to Centegra-Woodstock, private ambulances are being used to transport patients to other hospitals at their expense. (Insurance typically covers at least part of this cost, which can run in the thousands. WFRD ambulance trips come with a bill, too, ranging from about $500 to $900 for residents.) When patients call 911 for an ambulance, they will be taken directly to the hospital which can best treat them. Ambulance crews are directed by hospital doctors as to where to go.
Hill is worried that injured or sick people will decide to skip the ambulance altogether by driving themselves to the hospital when they’re in no shape to do so.
“Don’t be afraid to call 911. The most disturbing stories I’ve heard were of people that needed help and didn’t want to call the ambulance because they weren’t sure what was going to happen,” Hill said. “We, Woodstock Fire/Rescue District, are going to take care of you. We’re going to get you to the correct hospital and get you the treatment you need.”
thanks Dan
#1 by michael m on October 26, 2017 - 9:50 AM
From my understanding, Level I Trauma Centers loose a lot of money because they tend to get patients who do not have insurance and cannot pay their bill.
If you believe what Centegra says in the article, demand for inpatient beds is going down, and fewer beds will be needed. However, there is truth to the issue with hospitals going on bypass.
I know people who work at Sherman, from what they tell me, they are still very busy even with the Huntley hospital. The fact of the matter is the population is aging, and living longer, and sicker. Hospitals will still be needed.
#2 by Wayne on October 25, 2017 - 9:20 PM
Becoming a Level I trauma center has almost nothing to do with the physical facilities, although a new hospital can be built to facilitate better trauma care. Being a Level I traumade center is EXTREMELY expensive and requires a hospital to be a teaching facility. There’s a ton of educational requirements as well as a number of staff that need meet strict criteria on staff in the building 24/7. It isn’t as easy as just building a nice facility and throwing a couple bucks at the idea. It’s a long, expensive process to get certified and maintain that status.
#3 by Max O on October 25, 2017 - 7:47 PM
Yes I know Condell is level 1 Trauma Center, what I am saying is the I think a level 1 Truma Center is needed closer to the Waukegan/North Chicago area.
#4 by Mike on October 24, 2017 - 10:15 PM
Max Condell in Libertyville is a level 1 trauma center. The problem is now you have all the specialty hospitals: stroke center, pediatric trauma center, etc. and the state regulates all of that too. With both Sherman and Huntley hospitals being new it would have been a good idea to make one of them a level 1 trauma center too.
#5 by max o on October 24, 2017 - 4:09 PM
So how come no hospital group wants to have a Level I trauma center? Does demand have allot to do with it? I think the one of the vista hospitals in Waukegan for example could upgrade to a level I trauma center, I think Hospitals need to stop with these annoying wars. I think McHenry County needs at least another level II Trauma center in addition to McHenry Hospital.
#6 by Mike on October 23, 2017 - 7:17 PM
While another hospital in McHenry county is needed. Closing Woodstock is a bad idea. The population drives the n ed for an additional hospital to help lower transport times and give better quality care for patients. Lake county is in the same boat. The population has gone up but no new hospitals have been built. Whenever a hospital system wants to build one the others attack them not because of quality of patient care but that it will cause a financial impact and they will lose money. Meanwhile the hospitals are going on bypass several times a week. Just think of it this way. If it was you or your loved one would you be ok with a 15-17 minute transport time to the hospital with lights and sirens? As the old saying goes “when seconds count, we’re only minutes away.”
#7 by Michael M on October 23, 2017 - 1:13 PM
I have driven past the Woodstock Hospital, I can’t imagine that it has any more than 70 medical/surgical beds and 10 to 12 ICU beds. I understand that Ambulances will have to travel farther, but in this day and age, companies like Centegra need to find different ways to make a profit. I believe the current hospital is only 20 something years old. With that in mind, I would imagine that the hospital had semi private rooms. In todays world everyone wants private rooms. I have a friend who gave me a tour of Centegra Huntley. Right now, it is only half full, the reason is they do not have the staff or the beds to fully staff the whole hospital. According to the article, they will be moving the inpatient services and staff to Huntley and McHenry. Moving services to Huntley will do two things, 1 it should allow them to open up the other half of the hospital that is not open yet, and 2 it will give patients all private rooms! The way the units are set up at Huntley, they are A,B,C and D. Right now only the A and B sections of the units are open, hopefully with the addition of the Woodstock beds, they will at least be able to open up the C parts of all the units.
#8 by FFPMTom on October 22, 2017 - 11:15 PM
Thanks Drew
#9 by Drew Smith on October 22, 2017 - 8:34 PM
See http://www.nwherald.com/2017/06/21/centegra-health-system-to-suspend-most-inpatient-care-at-woodstock-hospital/a2g4nlo/
#10 by FFPMTom on October 22, 2017 - 8:07 PM
Anybody know why this hospital is cutting services?